fountain pen ink sheen affected by paper

How Different Papers Affect Fountain Pen Ink Sheen

John Bosley Paper 2 Comments

There is a lot of interest in sheening inks these days, and with good reason. Sheen can add visual interest and character to your writing. Sheening inks are also fun to use! In order to get the best sheen out of an ink, you’ll need to use the right paper. In this article, I want to take a look at how different papers affect fountain pen ink sheen. I think you’ll be surprised by the results!

Why Paper Matters

While you obviously need an ink that has sheen, you also need a paper that will show it. Even if you have an ink with high amounts of sheen, you’ll only be able to see it on certain types of paper. Why is this true? For a detailed explanation, you should read my article on sheen, but a basic explanation is that you need a paper that doesn’t absorb the ink too quickly and allows it to dry on the surface.

Some papers absorb ink more quickly than others, so this is why your choice of paper matters when you want your ink to sheen. If you use a cheap paper that absorbs the ink too quickly, not only is there a chance that it will feather and bleed, but it’s likely you won’t see any sheen either. So now that you understand why paper matters, let’s see how different papers affect sheen.

How Paper Affects Ink Sheen

To see how paper affects sheen, let’s look at a bunch of the most popular papers for use with fountain pens. Below you’ll find a variety of different papers that I’ve tested with the same inks. For each ink, I wrote normally and did a heavy scribble. While I didn’t use the same pen for every different ink, I did use the same pen for the same ink every time. You’ll see that the different papers do indeed affect how much sheen each ink shows.

About these photos: All photos were taken with the camera, lights and paper in the same position. The amount of sheen that you see is very dependent on the angle of your paper relative to a light source, so I kept all of the variables consistent so the amount of sheen you see would be true to the paper and not affected by anything else.

I’ve uploaded three photos for each paper sample. The first is a top-down view so you can clearly see what paper and inks were used. The second is a side view that shows the sheen for all of the inks. The third is a cropped version of the previous photo that shows the Yama-dori sheen in more detail.

The Inks And Their Sheen Colors

So that you have a reference point, I want to point out the color of each ink that I used and also its sheen color.

  • Paper Name: Visconti Blue – Blue Ink, Red Sheen
  • Sailor Yama-dori – Teal Ink, Red Sheen
  • Organics Studio Walden Pond – Green Ink, Red Sheen
  • Lamy Vibrant Pink – Pink Ink, Gold Sheen
  • PenBBS #276 – Red Ink, Gold Sheen
  • Iroshizuku Yama-budo – Purple Ink, Gold Sheen
  • J. Herbin Emerald of Chivor – Green Ink, Red Sheen, Gold Shimmer
Tomoe River

Typically considered to be the sheen king of paper, this one did not disappoint. Every ink sheened on this paper and many showed the most sheen out of any paper. The sheen for most of the inks is also the most intense on Tomoe River.

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen tomoe river

Tomoe River: Overview

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen tomoe river side view

Tomoe River: Side View

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen tomoe river sheen

Tomoe River: Sheen Detail

Life Noble

This paper easily holds its own against Tomoe River as far as sheen is concerned. Every ink showed a good amount of sheen.

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen life noble note

Life Noble Note: Overview

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen life noble note side view

Life Noble Note: Side View

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen life noble note sheen

Life Noble Note: Sheen Detail

Life “L” Writing Paper

Another great paper from Life. The “L” paper doesn’t show quite as much sheen as the Noble line of papers, but it still shows more than enough to make your writing fun and interesting.

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen life l writing paper

Life L. Writing Paper: Overview

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen life l writing paper side view

Life L. Writing Paper: Side View

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen life l writing paper sheen

Life L. Writing Paper: Sheen Detail

Midori MD

This is one of my favorite papers and it shows a lot of sheen. I would say it is comparable to the Life Noble.

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen midori md

Midori MD: Overview

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen midori md side view

Midori MD: Side View

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen midori md sheen

Midori MD: Sheen Detail

Rhodia

Rhodia is a very fountain pen friendly paper, but does not do so well with sheen. While it does show a bit of sheen for all of the inks, it is very weak and hard to see for most. Rhodia is nice if you want a nice, inexpensive paper to write on, but not if you want to see a lot of sheen.

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen rhodia

Rhodia: Overview

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen rhodia side view

Rhodia: Side View

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen rhodia sheen

Rhodia: Sheen Detail

Fabriano EcoQua

Another one of my favorite papers, Fabriano EcoQua notebooks have paper that shows a surprising amount of sheen for their cost. While it’s not as much as some of the premium papers, it is enough to make your ink look good.

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen fabriano ecoqua notebook

Fabriano EcoQua: Overview

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen fabriano ecoqua notebook sheen

Fabriano EcoQua: Side View

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen fabriano ecoqua notebook detail

Fabriano EcoQua: Sheen Detail

Apica Premium C.D.

I had high hopes for this paper and must admit I am pretty disappointed in how much sheen it shows. The notebooks cost as much as Life Noble Notebooks, so I expected a similar experience. Sadly, this wasn’t the case. Some inks like Emerald of Chivor showed almost no sheen at all! While it is nice paper, if you want to buy a notebook that will give you a lot of sheen, go for one made by Life or Midori.

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen apica premium cd

Apica Premium CD: Overview

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen apica premium cd side view

Apica Premium CD: Side View

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen apica premium cd sheen

Apica Premium CD: Sheen Detail

HP Premium Laser 32lb

People love this paper because it is inexpensive, smooth and fountain pen friendly. It is not a high-sheening paper. Most of the inks showed a bit of sheen, but not an impressive amount. If you want a cheap paper that’s nice to write on, this is a good choice. If you want to see a lot of sheen, this is not a good choice.

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen hp 32lb premium

HP 32lb Premium Laser: Overview

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen hp 32lb premium side view

HP 32lb Premium Laser: Side View

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen hp 32lb premium detail

HP 32lb Premium Laser: Sheen Detail

Clairfontaine Triomphe

This was probably my biggest surprise out of all of the papers. It shows a lot of sheen, which I was not expecting from a non-Japanese paper. It also might be the smoothest paper of the bunch. If you’re looking for an ultra-smooth paper that shows a lot of sheen, this should be at the top of your list.

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen Clairfontaine triomphe

Clairfontaine Triomphe: Overview

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen Clairfontaine triomphe side view

Clairfontaine Triomphe: Side View

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen Clairfontaine triomphe sheen detail

Clairfontaine Triomphe: Sheen Detail

G. Lalo Verge de France

This paper shows some sheen, but not nearly as much as I had hoped. I think you would buy this paper for the writing experience and reader experience and not so much for how much sheen it shows.

You might also notice that this is “laid” paper, which means it has lines running across it from the manufacturing process. If you’ve used this type of paper before, you’ll probably notice I wrote across it going against the pattern. I did this because I cut a piece of A4 paper in half and used it like an A5, which rotated the lines 90-degrees. If you’re wondering, I wouldn’t recommend this, as it makes writing a little more difficult.

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen g lalo

G. Lalo Verge de France: Overview

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen g lalo side view

G. Lalo Verge de France: Side View

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen g lalo sheen

G. Lalo Verge de France: Sheen Detail

Maruman Cover Note

I added this notebook to the roundup because of how little sheen it shows. I bought it to use as my daily planner and, going strictly from how the paper felt, I imagined it would be a premium paper. While it is nice to write on, imagine my disappointment when I saw almost no sheen from any ink I used. This just goes to show that you can’t assume a paper will show sheen just because it’s nice and smooth.

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen maruman cover note

Maruman Cover Note: Overview

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen maruman cover note side view

Maruman Cover Note: Side View

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen maruman cover note sheen

Maruman Cover Note: Sheen Detail

Generic Copy Paper

As expected, generic copy paper showed no sheen for any inks except for the Organics Studio (which speaks much more to the ink than to the paper). Unless you have no other choice, you shouldn’t use copy paper with your fountain pens.

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen copy paper

Copy Paper: Overview

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen copy paper side view

Copy Paper: Side View

How does paper affect fountain pen ink sheen copy paper sheen

Copy Paper: Sheen Detail

Conclusions

You can see that, while the majority of inks showed sheen on most of the papers, the amount of sheen did indeed change depending on which paper was used. The paper that showed the least amount of sheen, the generic copy paper, is also the lowest-quality paper in the test and is not something you would want to use with your fountain pens. As for the highest amount of sheen, I don’t know if one stands out above the rest, but there is definitely a correlation to the quality (and cost) of paper and the amount of sheen that it shows.

I found it interesting that the texture and, more specifically the writing feel, of a paper does not correlate to how much sheen it shows. The Midori MD offers some feedback and the Clairfontaine Triomphe is extremely smooth, but both show about the same amount of sheen. Furthermore, the Maruman Cover Note is very smooth paper that I would compare to Life “L” paper, but shows almost no sheen at all.

When comparing the same inks side-by-side on different papers, I noticed something that I had never really thought about before. While an ink might have sheened on a lot of different papers, the intensity of the sheen was different. For example, Sailor Yama-dori showed nearly the same amount of sheen on Tomoe River versus Fabriano EcoQua, but the color and boldness of the sheen was more pronounced on the Tomoe River. Maybe this is why some papers show off sheen better than others… it’s simply easier to see because it stands out more. While there are definitely papers that simply sheen more than others, this sheen intensity likely plays a role in how much sheen we perceive.

One thing to note is that higher amounts of sheen typically relate to longer drying times, so some of the papers with the highest amount of sheen like Tomoe River also have some of the longest drying times. If you need your writing to dry more quickly, you might have to sacrifice some sheen.

Papers In This Test

 Paper NameAmount of SheenComments
Tomoe RiverHighIf you want sheen, this should be your top paper choice.
Life NobleHighThis is one of the highest-quality papers around.
Life "L" WritingHighIf you write a lot of letters and use sheening inks, you should find some of this paper.
Midori MDHighMidori MD journals are some of my personal favorites and they show a great amount of sheen.
RhodiaLowAlthough Rhodia is fountain pen friendly, it does not show very much sheen.
Fabriano EcoQuaMediumMy favorite budget notebook, this paper probably has the best price-to-sheen ratio.
Apica Premium C.D.MediumMy biggest disappointment of the bunch, I expected a lot more sheen than this paper gave me.
HP Premium Laser 32lbLowAnother great paper that is fountain pen friendly but doesn't show much sheen.
Clairfontaine TriompheHighMy biggest surprise, this paper shows a lot of sheen, in addition to being amazingly smooth.
G. Lalo Verge de FranceMediumDoesn't show as much sheen as the other premium-priced papers, but is the only laid paper in the roundup.
Maruman Cover Note NotebookAlmost NoneNice paper to write on, but shows almost no sheen.
Generic Copy PaperAlmost NoneIf you use a fountain pen, don't use cheap copy paper.

Hi, my name is John. I’m a Colorado-born professional photographer who recently moved back to Denver after spending 3 years in San Francisco. I’ve been using and collecting fountain pens for over 20 years. I got my first one in college when I got bored taking notes with ballpoints and pencils. Since then I’ve bought and sold hundreds of pens, but have consistency in my love of Esterbrooks.

Comments 2

  1. Thanks for this neat, detailed comparison. I’m curious if there’s something about Rhodia paper’s coated vellum that resists sheening, despite its smoothness. I ask because I’ve found it to be smoother than Life or Midori.

    1. Post
      Author

      You are very welcome, Steve. There might be something to that. One of these days I’m going to do more research on the coatings that are used on papers and compare how they effect the writing experience.

Leave a Reply