how to polish a fountain pen nib waterman 5a

How To Polish A Fountain Pen Nib

John Bosley How To 11 Comments

If you ever start using or collecting vintage fountain pens, chances are you’ll end up with a nib that is no longer shiny. While it may still work just fine, wouldn’t it be nice if it looked good, too? I’ve got a very simple trick that you can use to shine up almost any gold nib that has seen better days.

Polishing A Fountain Pen Nib

You’ve probably used a silver polishing cloth to make your jewelry or silverware shine like new. Well guess what… you can do the same thing with your fountain pen nibs! Simply use a polishing cloth on your nibs and carefully wipe away the years of tarnish. I say carefully because you don’t want to snag the tip of your nib in the cloth and either drop your pen or bend your nib. On less expensive, plated nibs, you can also rub away the gold plating with too much polishing.

My preferred technique is to start near the pen body and wipe towards the tip of the nib. Ideally, instead of holding the pen stationary and moving the cloth, you will hold the cloth stationary and move the nib across it. Both of these techniques will minimize the chances of you accidentally dropping the pen that you’re working on. As an added precaution, be sure to work over a soft surface like carpet in case you do drop your pen. You can also work on specific trouble spots by polishing in very small circles. You’ll want to be more careful near the very tip of the nib so you don’t damage it.

I’ve found that spending anywhere from 30 seconds to 2 minutes on a nib can make it look completely different! Take a look at the nib below. There was a little discoloration near the tip of the nib. This is pretty common for older gold nibs. With a little work, the discoloration was removed and the nib was shining like new.

how to polish a fountain pen nib moore

Before: You can see some slight discoloration near the tip of this nib and around the breather hole.

how to polish a fountain pen nib moore maniflex

After: After a quick polishing, it’s gone!

Here are another two nibs that were looking a little dull. Again, by spending less than a minute polishing each nib, they were gleaming!

how to polish a fountain pen nib waterman keyhole

Before: These two nibs have lost a lot of their original shine.

how to polish a fountain pen nib waterman flexible nib

After: It just took a little polishing to make them both look much better!

In some extreme cases, you can hardly tell that the nib started out gold. This Waterman nib looked horrible before I polished it. It had years of tarnish and I wasn’t sure it was going to clean up at all. While it took a little more work than the other nibs I’ve shown you, it still only took about 2 minutes to make it look like a completely different nib!

how to polish a fountain pen nib waterman 5a

Before: Is there any hope for this nib? It doesn’t even look like it’s gold anymore!

how to polish a fountain pen nib half done

Just for fun, I polished half of this nib and left the other half untouched.

how to polish a fountain pen nib waterman gold nib

After: Here’s the finished nib. What a difference! Compare it to the “before” photo to see how much better it looks.

A Few Notes

I’ve mentioned gold nibs this entire time. Will this work to remove rust from steel nibs? Unfortunately, it won’t. These polishing cloths only work to remove tarnish. If you have an old steel nib that is rusted or has other discolorations, this technique won’t work to clean it up. It also won’t completely remove all wear on a nib. If you look closely at that nib that was heavily tarnished, there are still a few darker spots that I couldn’t remove where I’m afraid the actual nib was cosmetically damaged. It’s possible they could be polished out, but I wasn’t able to with a polishing cloth.

Another step that I would recommend is to clean and wash your nib after polishing it. Silver polishing cloths work because they have a very fine polishing compound embedded in them. While it may not be bad to get this into your ink when you fill your pen, it’s always best to not take any chances and clean your pen before filling it. As you can see in the last photos, you’ll also end up with some fibers from the cloth on your pen, so by washing it off, you will remove any small fibers that might be sticking to your pen.

So that’s it! If you have any vintage pens with gold nibs that could use a polish, give this method a try. You’ll be amazed at how quick and easy it is. BONUS: this cloth also works on some vintage pen trim, although for heavy polishing you’ll probably want to use a polishing compound like Simichrome.

Disclaimer: Any time you are working on a pen, do not attempt anything that is outside of your comfort or skill level. If you are unsure whether or not your pen may be damaged, it is best to have a professional do the repair.

Hi, my name is John. I’m a Colorado-born professional photographer who recently moved back to Denver after spending 3 years in San Francisco. I’ve been using and collecting fountain pens for over 20 years. I got my first one in college when I got bored taking notes with ballpoints and pencils. Since then I’ve bought and sold hundreds of pens, but have consistency in my love of Esterbrooks.

Comments 11

    1. Post
      Author
    1. Post
      Author
    1. Post
      Author
  1. Ahhhh, now I understand what’s up with the nib on one of my acquired vintage pens. I just thought I’d have to live with the discolouration, ahaha.

    1. Post
      Author
  2. I don’t know if this is truly a concern or not, but I would probably remove the nib before polishing so that I didn’t get any of the polishing compound on the section or barrel of the pen, or perhaps tape the section with masking tape. Depending on the type of solvent added to the polishing cloth or compound and the type of material used in the section of the pen, there could be unintended consequences. Maybe. As I say, I don’t know this for a fact, just something I’d do as a precaution.

    1. Post
      Author

      While I’d never recommend you do anything that you’re not comfortable with, in my opinion removing the nib and taping the section are overkill. You probably have a higher chance of damaging your pen by removing the nib or putting tape on it. Of course, some vintage pen materials are quite fragile and even unstable, so if it’s a very valuable pen you can never be too careful!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.